Justice Delayed: The Long-Overdue Arrest of Prophet Walter Magaya – A Trail of Allegations from Rape to Fraud

By Abel Karowangoro

As the sun rose over Harare’s bustling streets, a fleet of unmarked police vehicles descended on the opulent offices of Prophetic Healing and Deliverance (PHD) Ministries. Their target: Walter Magaya, the self-proclaimed prophet whose sermons have drawn thousands seeking miracles, but whose shadow has long been darkened by whispers of abuse, deceit, and death.

The 41-year-old cleric, founder of one of Zimbabwe’s largest Pentecostal empires, was arrested on multiple counts of rape and fraud,  charges that echo a decade of unresolved accusations.

For victims, survivors, and observers alike, this moment feels not like a bolt from the blue, but a reckoning long overdue.

Zimbabwe Republic Police spokesperson Commissioner Paul Nyathi confirmed the dawn raid in a terse statement:

“ZRP confirms the arrest of PHD Church leader Walter Magaya in connection with several reports of rape and fraud. The suspect was arrested early today by a police crack team.”

Details remain sparse, but sources close to the investigation suggest the charges stem from fresh complaints lodged in recent months, building on a litany of prior allegations that have dogged Magaya since his meteoric rise in 2012. What began as claims of divine healing has devolved into a sordid saga of exploitation, with critics arguing that Magaya’s influence,  bolstered by political ties and a vast media machine, shielded him from accountability until now.

The Rape Allegations: A Pattern of Power and Predation

Magaya’s troubles with sexual misconduct allegations date back nearly a decade, painting a picture of a leader who allegedly weaponised his spiritual authority against vulnerable congregants.

The first major storm broke In August 2016, when a 25-year-old Midlands State University student accused him of rape.

According to court records, Magaya allegedly invited the woman to his Mount Pleasant home under the guise of a private counselling session.

He reportedly left her alone in a room, only to return nude and assault her, later offering US$200 as hush money.

The case thrust Magaya into the spotlight, with leaked audio recordings purportedly capturing discussions of financial settlements to silence the accuser.

The complainant, known only as Mandi (not real name) in court documents, withdrew her charges two months later amid claims of death threats from unknown assailants pressuring her to proceed.

Affidavits slipped under the door of the Harare Magistrates Court detailed her fear, yet failed to explain the reversal despite the alleged intimidation.

Magaya, granted bail and ordered to surrender his passport, maintained his innocence, framing the ordeal as a divine test that only strengthened his resolve.

But this was no isolated incident. In June 2019, a couple from Chitungwiza, Godfrey and Molly Maenzanise, went public with explosive claims that Magaya had impregnated their 17-year-old daughter, whom he had “adopted” after they couldn’t afford her school fees.

The family alleged he abused her repeatedly, shattering her confidence and leaving her pregnant.

The daughter, in a video response, denied the assault and stood by Magaya, a retraction that fueled suspicions of coercion.

Days later, The Sunday Mail reported two more women – Sarah Maruta and Charity Dhlodhlo, accusing him of rape and serial abuse of young female congregants.

Maruta later recanted via video, claiming extortion attempts by the media, but critics pointed to a pattern: accusers retracting under pressure, often after promises of financial aid or threats

The Zimbabwe Gender Commission (ZGC) launched a probe in 2019, only for Magaya to challenge it in court.

In October 2021, the Supreme Court dismissed his appeal, affirming the ZGC’s right to investigate. Yet, no charges stuck – until now. Today’s arrest revives these ghosts, with insiders suggesting the “several reports” include revived 2019 cases, as public pressure mounted via social media and protests.

“It’s poetic justice,” one anonymous former congregant told this outlet. “He preyed on our faith; now the law has to step in.”

The Murder Case: Shadows of Death in the Sanctuary

If the rape allegations exposed Magaya’s alleged personal predations, darker clouds gathered around claims of negligence and cover-ups leading to death.

In July 2014, a Dotito woman accused the prophet of manslaughter after her seven-week-old baby boy died mysteriously during a PHD healing service in Harare.

Police investigated Magaya directly, probing whether “exorcism” rituals or unqualified interventions contributed to the infant’s demise.

The case, which coincided with government plans to brand Magaya a “tourist attraction” for religious tourism, quietly fizzled – a harbinger of leniency to come.

More recently, the 2019 medical fraud conviction was intertwined with fatalities.

Magaya was fined US$700 for peddling an unapproved herbal “cure” for HIV/AIDS, a potion he claimed could eradicate the virus. The World Health Organisation and Zimbabwean authorities condemned it as dangerous quackery.

During a police raid, Magaya’s team allegedly flushed sachets down toilets and burned containers to destroy evidence.

At least four congregants reportedly died after ingesting the substance, their families alleging Magaya’s false promises hastened fatal outcomes.

The plot thickened In March 2024, when six women stormed a PHD service, confronting Magaya on stage over “Chipo’s murder” alongside rape and fraud claims. Chipo, a congregant, allegedly died under suspicious circumstances linked to church activities, with protesters demanding justice for her and others. That September, reports surfaced of Magaya fleeing Zimbabwe after his bodyguard, Liberty Chinembiri, was gruesomely murdered at the Yadah Hotel – a property tied to the prophet’s business empire. Whispers of internal foul play swirled, but no charges followed.

Even as recently as December 2024, the dismembered body of Lindi Chamunorwa – described as Magaya’s “girlfriend” – was discovered in Kwekwe, initially ruled a car accident but later revealed via X-rays to bear machete wounds, suggesting murder.

Sources close to the probe hinted at ties to Magaya’s circle, though he denied involvement.

These threads – negligence, cover-ups, and outright violence – weave a narrative of a ministry where miracles masked mortal risks.

Fraud Allegations: From Fake Cures to Forged Futures

Magaya’s financial improprieties form the third pillar of his downfall, a web of deceit that enriched him while impoverishing followers.

Beyond the HIV scam, he faced a US$23 million debt lawsuit in 2019 from Homelink over a failed Yadah Connect housing scheme, where congregants lost life savings on promised stands that never materialised.

In March 2024, protesters again stormed his service, one woman demanding US$500,000 her family allegedly lost to Magaya’s schemes – part of claims from nearly 100 victims, including Israeli investors.

The latest fraud bombshell exploded in January 2025, when Magaya’s bid for Zimbabwe Football Association (ZIFA) presidency crumbled over fake O-Level certificates.

Disqualified for lacking qualifications, he escalated to the High Court with a forged University of South Africa (UNISA) marketing diploma and honorary PhD – documents UNISA swiftly disavowed.

The university confirmed: “UNISA has no record of Walter Magaya as a student or graduate. Any certificate he produces… is fraudulent.”

The Zimbabwe Anti-Corruption Commission (ZACC) launched a probe on January 31, 2025, potentially facing 20 years under fraud statutes.

Additional woes include a February 2025 High Court interdict halting his unauthorized Chitungwiza developments and a Bulawayo stands scam defrauding congregants. In August 2025, U.S. authorities raised airport alerts over his unlicensed medical practices during a planned Dallas visit.

Why Now? A Prophet Unmasked

Magaya’s arrest caps a year of unravelling: from UNISA’s fraud exposure to mounting protests and ZACC scrutiny. Supporters decry it as “persecution,” timed suspiciously before his “Night of Turn Around” event. For the aggrieved, the assaulted, the bereaved, the swindled – it’s vindication.

“He built an empire on our pain,” one victim shared anonymously. As Magaya awaits court, questions linger: Will justice prevail, or will influence intervene again?

This is a developing story. PHD Ministries has yet to comment. Stay tuned for updates.